• All orders must be called in by phone or placed online.
  • All payments must be made by credit card over the phone or online.
  • If you are picking up an order please let us know when you are at our location and we will bring your order out to you. If you prefer contactless pick up, we can place your order directly into the cargo area of your vehicle.
  • If you are having food delivered, upon arrival our driver will leave your order at the front of your home or building and then call you to notify you. You will not be required to interact with the driver. (Gratuities may be added to your credit card when your order is placed.)


We are Sorry for any inconvenience these new policies may cause, however we feel they are necessary for us to continue operating safely through this crisis.


Temporary Hours

Monday Thru Wednesday 10am – 7pm
Thursday & Friday 10am – 8pm
Saturday 11am – 8pm
Sunday – Closed


Please Plan Accordingly
Stay Safe & Stay Well

Slice Reviews

s star review from Slice 140 votes

Grub Hub Reviews

s star review 53 votes

Yelp Reviews

4 star review 104 reviews

Doordash Reviews

4 1/2 Stars from Doordash 35 votes

Garden City Pizza Exterior View

Garden City Pizza & Catering Chef Cooking

Garden City Pizza & Catering

Offering age-old tradition and timeless recipes that have been passed down through generations. Garden City Pizza is best known for its clean friendly atmosphere and fresh home made Italian specialties. At Garden City Pizza we offer FREE local delivery to all of our neighbors Whether you order one of our many specialty Pizza Pies, Pastas, Salads, Heroes or Panini’s we deliver to you. Catering is our speciality from a cozy dinner for two, to a wedding for two hundred. Let Garden City Pizza and Catering handle your next special occasion.

What people are saying about Garden City Pizza

Garden City Pizza is your local neighborhood pizza restaurant!

This place has AMAZING pizza! We are visiting garden city for a cousin’s wedding from Canada! I had chicken parm pizza and my hubby had chicken bacon ranch pizza. We also split garlic bread and a broccoli wheel. It was all soooo good! The staff was very helpful and had great customer service skills. The restaurant was clean and had indoor and outdoor seating. Quick service and fresh pizza! Thanks friends! Can’t wait to come back one day!

Gillian G

posted on, Google Reviews

From the days of the Italian Kitchen back in the 70s until now under the direction of Greg, folks can enjoy eating pizza of all kinds as well as great salads and entrees. Always a favorite dining spot, Greg generously supports a number of community endeavors and brings an array of delectable’s such as garlic knot sandwiches, shrimp Caesar salad slices, and more. Their pizza is always good, and my favorite is their lasagna pizza. It has lots of meat, cheese, and sauce. So next time you have a party, ask Greg to cater to it as your guests will enjoy every bite.

Jacqueline V

posted on, Google Reviews

Great Quality Pizza selection. This Pizzeria never has a full moment, consistently providing it’s menu selection from Open > Close every single day it’s open. Always operating at full efficiency with the service you would and should expect at every Eat-In / Take-Out Restaurant. No disappointments eating at this place. I do like the more eco-friendly straws they provide, every little bit counts. We should all be finding ways to leave less of a footprint with our waste and recycables.

Colby J

posted on, Google Reviews



Call (516) 294-2929 to order !

View Menu

Join Us on Facebook Stay in touch and receive special offers via Facebook.

See Instagram photos and videos from Garden City Pizza and Catering.

Follow Us on Twitter View the latest News, Events, specials and the latest deals.